personal injury lawyers

Fighting for maximum injury compensation for you and your family

No Fees Until We Win

What to Do If the Other Driver Refuses to Share Insurance

Encountering a car accident is stressful, but when the other driver refuses to share insurance information, it adds a layer of complexity to an already challenging situation.

In New Jersey, like in many places, it’s essential to exchange insurance information after an accident to facilitate a smooth claims process. 

However, what do you do when the other driver refuses to share their insurance details? This article aims to guide you through the steps you should take in such a situation, providing clear and practical advice for processing through the complexities of dealing with uncooperative drivers.

What to Do If the Other Driver Refuses to Share Insurance

How to Deal With The Insurance And Uninsurance Drivers in New Jersey?

Dealing with insurance matters in New Jersey requires a strategic approach, especially when faced with uncooperative drivers. Here’s what you should do:

Call the Police

The first and immediate step is to contact law enforcement. The involvement of the police is pivotal for several reasons. 

A police report not only documents the incident but also becomes instrumental in the later stages of the claims process. 

For instance, if the uncooperative driver attempts to deny involvement or contests the events, a police report serves as an official record, providing clarity on the situation. 

Contact Your Insurance Adjuster

Promptly reach out to your insurance company. Inform them about the situation, emphasizing the other driver’s refusal to share insurance details. 

Your insurance adjuster is your ally in going through the claims process smoothly. They can guide the next steps, ensuring that you fulfill your obligations and receive the support you need. 

For example, if the other driver remains uncooperative, your insurance adjuster may advise you on the necessary documentation to strengthen your claim.

Gather Important Evidence

Documenting the scene thoroughly is important for building a strong case. Take pictures of the accident, capturing the extent of vehicle damages and any relevant road signs.

Additionally, note the time and date of the incident. This evidence serves not only as a personal record but can also be necessary during insurance proceedings or legal actions. 

For instance, if there is a dispute about the cause of the accident, photographic evidence can provide a clear depiction of the conditions at the time.

Check for Any Eye-Witness

If there were spectators who witnessed the accident, take the initiative to gather their contact information. Independent eyewitness accounts can be invaluable in supporting your case. 

In case of disputes, their statements can provide an unbiased perspective, strengthening your position during the claims process or potential legal actions. Consider this as an additional layer of support for your version of events.

Exchange Information with the Uncooperative Driver

Attempt to exchange information with the uncooperative driver again, emphasizing the legal obligation to share insurance details after an accident.

Politely insist on obtaining their full name, contact information, insurance details, and vehicle information. Sometimes, a calm and persistent approach can encourage cooperation.

Seek Legal Advice

In cases of persistent non-cooperation, seeking legal advice becomes crucial. Consult with a car accident attorney, who specializes in handling such situations.

An attorney can provide insights into the legal options available to you and can take proactive measures to compel the uncooperative driver to comply with their legal obligations.

See also: How Do I File a Claim Against an Uninsured Driver In NJ

How Can I File An Insurance Claim When The Other Driver Would Not Provide Any Insurance Information?

Filing an insurance claim without the other driver’s information may seem challenging, but it’s not impossible. Here are the steps to guide you through the process:

  1. Immediately Call the Police: Dial 911 if there are injuries or the non-emergency police line for non-injury accidents. The police will create an official report, which is vital for your insurance claim.
  2. Contact Your Insurance Company: Reach out to your insurance company promptly. Provide them with the police report number and details of the accident. Local companies, like ABC Insurance at Main Street, Newark, are familiar with New Jersey cases and can guide you through the process.
  3. Gather Solid Evidence: Take pictures of the accident scene, including the damages to your vehicle and any relevant road signs. If the accident happened near a well-known place, like the Johnson Manufacturing plant in Trenton, mention it for clarity. Note the date and time of the incident.
  4. Seek Witness Accounts: If there were eyewitnesses, ask for their contact information. Independent witnesses can provide valuable statements to support your case.

Get Help From A Car Accident Attorney in New Jersey

When dealing with the after-effects of an accident and an uncooperative driver, seeking legal assistance is a smart move. A seasoned car accident attorney, like the professionals at Rosengard Law Group, can be your guiding force. 

They specialize in New Jersey cases and understand the intricacies of the local legal field. And ensures that experienced professionals are advocating for your rights. 


Is it illegal if a driver refuses to provide their information after a car accident in New Jersey?

Yes, it is illegal for drivers involved in an accident in New Jersey to refuse to share their insurance information. Failure to exchange information can result in fines, license suspension, or other legal consequences.

What information should you get from other drivers if involved in a car accident?

Full name and contact information, insurance details, including the policy number and insurance company, vehicle details, and driver’s license information.


Encountering a driver who refuses to share insurance information can be a daunting experience, but it’s important to remain composed and follow the necessary steps. 

By promptly involving the police, contacting your insurance company, gathering evidence, and seeking legal assistance, you can protect your interests and ensure a smoother resolution. 

Remember, cooperation and compliance with the law are key elements in processing the consequences of a car accident. 

Stay informed, be prepared, and seek the guidance you need to handle the complex aspect of insurance claims in New Jersey.

Free Injury Case Evaluation

Send the form below and we will call you back in minutes.

…or Call Us Now