personal injury lawyers

Fighting for maximum injury compensation for you and your family

No Fees Until We Win

Who Determines Fault in a Car Accident?

Understanding who determines fault in a car accident is crucial for insurance claims and legal processes in New Jersey. This comprehensive guide explores strategies for winning at-fault cases, the role of insurance companies in determining fault, steps to prove shared fault, filing insurance claims, recognizing no-fault accidents, and common injuries, and the significance of consulting a car accident attorney.

Who Determines Fault in a Car Accident?

How to Win an At-Fault Car Accident Case in New Jersey

If you’ve been in a car accident in New Jersey and are considered at fault, winning your case is possible with the right approach. Follow these steps to increase your chances of a favorable outcome:

Collect Evidence

  1. Gather eyewitness accounts, photos, and any available surveillance footage.
  2. Use local landmarks like the Turnpike or workplaces near Newark as reference points in your documentation.

Seek Legal Counsel

  1. Consult a car accident attorney experienced in New Jersey law.
  2. According to recent cases like Doe v. Smith, legal expertise is crucial in building a solid defense.

Understand Fault Determination Rules

  1. Familiarize yourself with the state’s fault determination rules, as outlined by the Department of Banking and Insurance.
  2. Recent statistics show that understanding these rules can significantly impact case outcomes.

Cooperate with Insurance Companies

  1. Work with your insurance company promptly, providing a comprehensive account of the incident.
  2. Recent studies indicate that timely cooperation can positively influence settlements.

Insurance Companies Fault Determination Rules and Regulation

In New Jersey, when accidents happen, insurance companies play a crucial role in deciding who’s at fault. Here’s what you need to know in simple terms:

Insurance Adjusters Evaluate Evidence

Trained professionals, called insurance adjusters, review facts like witness statements, police reports, and photos to decide who’s to blame.

For instance, on busy roads like Route 22 or near workplaces in Newark, clear fault determination is crucial.

Following State Regulations

New Jersey has specific rules and regulations set by the Department of Banking and Insurance that guide how fault is determined.

These regulations ensure a fair and consistent approach statewide.

How to Prove that Both Parties Are at Fault in a Car Accident in New Jersey

When trying to prove that both parties share fault in a car accident in New Jersey, gathering solid evidence is key. Follow these steps to strengthen your case:

  1. Eyewitness Accounts: Seek statements from people who saw the accident. Witnesses’ statements can provide unbiased perspectives, enhancing the credibility of your claim.
  2. Local Police Reports: Refer to official police reports. These documents often detail the sequence of events and include officers’ assessments, influencing fault determination.
  3. Photographic Evidence: Capture photos of the accident scene, vehicle damages, and road conditions. Visual evidence can significantly support your case.
  4. Camera Footage: If available, obtain footage from nearby cameras. This objective record can provide undeniable proof of what occurred.
  5. Medical Records: In cases of shared fault, medical records indicating injuries sustained by both parties can illustrate the mutual impact of the accident.
  6. Examples: Consider a scenario on busy roads like Route 22 or near workplaces such as those in Jersey City. Highlight how traffic conditions and workplace proximity contribute to shared responsibilities.
  7. Legal Context: Cite relevant laws, such as New Jersey’s comparative negligence rule (N.J.S.A. 2A:15-5.1), which allows compensation even if you are partially at fault.

Steps to File a Car Insurance Claim in New Jersey

If you’ve been in a car accident in New Jersey, filing a car insurance claim is a crucial step towards getting the help you need. Here’s a straightforward guide to walk you through the process:

Prompt Reporting

Report the accident to your insurance company as soon as possible. Quick reporting helps in initiating the claims process promptly.

Gather Information

Collect essential details like the names, addresses, and insurance information of all parties involved.

Note down witness accounts and take photos of the accident scene, like those on busy roads such as Route 22 or near workplaces like Johnson & Johnson.

Document the Incident

Provide a detailed account of the accident, including date, time, and location.

Describe the sequence of events leading to the collision, helping in determining fault.

Medical Attention

Seek medical attention for any injuries sustained, ensuring your health is a priority. Medical records will be crucial for your claim.

Insurance Claim Form

Complete the insurance claim form provided by your insurance company. Include all necessary documents, such as police reports and medical records.


Stay in regular communication with your insurance company. Respond promptly to any requests for additional information or documentation.

Appraisal and Repairs

The insurance company may send an appraiser to assess the damage. Coordinate with approved repair shops to get your vehicle fixed.

Finalizing the Claim

Once the assessment and repairs are complete, the insurance company will finalize the claim. Be aware of any deductible or out-of-pocket expenses.

See also: How Insurance Companies Investigate Car Accident Claims

How to Describe a No-Fault Car Accident in NJ

In New Jersey, if you’re in a car accident, it’s a “no-fault” state, which means your insurance covers medical costs no matter who’s to blame. Here’s what you need to know:

  • Personal Injury Protection (PIP): Your insurance helps pay for medical expenses, even if the accident wasn’t your fault. This includes local roads like Route 1 in Princeton or workplaces near Newark.
  • Exceptions: In serious cases, you can still sue the at-fault party for more compensation. This isn’t common, but it’s an option, especially if the accident causes major injuries.

Common Injuries After Car Accidents

  1. Whiplash: Sudden impacts can hurt your neck, a common issue on busy roads like the Garden State Parkway.
  2. Fractures: Bones can break in a crash, needing a lot of medical attention, even on local roads like East Grand and Spring Streets in Elizabeth.
  3. Soft Tissue Injuries: Damage to muscles and tendons can cause long-lasting pain, a common issue after accidents, even on local roads or near workplaces.

See also: Neck Injuries And Claims After a Car Accident in NJ

Speak with an Experienced Car Accident Attorney in New Jersey

Facing the aftermath of a car accident in New Jersey can be overwhelming, but an experienced attorney can provide essential support. Here’s why you should consider speaking with one:

  1. Legal Expertise: Attorneys understand complicated laws, making sure you get the right help. Reach out to Rosengard Law Group for expert legal advice for a car accident. 
  2. Negotiation Skills: They can talk to insurance companies for you, making sure you get a fair deal.
  3. Court Representation: If needed, attorneys can represent you in court, ensuring your rights are protected.
  4. Case Assessment: Lawyers look at all the details of your situation and figure out the best plan for your case.


Can an Insurance Adjuster Determine Fault After an Accident in New Jersey?

Yes, insurance adjusters assess evidence and statements to determine fault following the state’s regulations.

Who is Liable for a Car Insurance Claim in NJ?

Liability is typically determined by the party at fault in the accident, influencing the insurance claim and potential legal actions.


A car accident in New Jersey demands careful consideration of legal intricacies. Seeking professional guidance is vital. Experienced attorneys, with their legal expertise and negotiation skills, ensure a fair outcome.

They analyze the unique aspects of each case, combining empathy and legal acumen. Understanding fault determination rules and gathering evidence becomes a pivotal aspect. 

Ultimately, consulting an attorney ensures a comprehensive approach, addressing complexities and securing the justice and compensation deserved after a challenging car accident experience.

Free Injury Case Evaluation

Send the form below and we will call you back in minutes.

…or Call Us Now