personal injury lawyers

Fighting for maximum injury compensation for you and your family

No Fees Until We Win

Why So Many Personal Injury Cases Settle Out of Court?

The legal world can be a tricky place. One thing you might have heard is that a lot of personal injury cases don’t end up in front of a judge and jury. Instead, they get settled outside of court. You might have often wondered why, below are a few reasons.

Why So Many Personal Injury Cases Settle Out of Court

What Is Alternative Dispute Resolution?

Alternative Dispute Resolution, often shortened to ADR, is like a toolbox full of different ways to solve disagreements without going to court. One popular method is mediation, where a neutral third person helps both sides talk it out and come to an agreement. Another method is arbitration, where someone listens to both sides and then makes a decision, kind of like a judge, but in a less formal setting.

Advantages of Out-of-Court Settlements

There are several good reasons people choose to settle their personal injury cases outside of court:

  • Cost: Court trials can be expensive. Think about it – hiring a lawyer for a long trial, the fees, the time taken from work, and other expenses can all add up. Settling outside of court can often save both sides money.
  • Time: Trials can last a very long time, sometimes even years. Settling can wrap things up much faster.
  • Certainty: With a trial, there’s always the risk of losing. Settling ensures both parties have control over the outcome.
  • Privacy: Court proceedings are public. If you settle outside of court, details remain confidential.

Drawbacks of Out of Court Settlements

Of course, there are also downsides to avoiding court:

  • Potentially Lower Compensation: Sometimes, the settlement amount might be less than what could have been awarded in court.
  • No Legal Precedent: Settling a case means there’s no legal precedent set, which could be important in similar future cases.
  • No “Day in Court”: For some, having their day in court is a form of closure or justice. Settling doesn’t provide this opportunity.

Why People Prefer to Settle Out of Court

Given the pros and cons, many opt for settling out of court because it’s less stressful. The idea of going to court, facing the person or company they’re up against, and dealing with the unpredictability of a trial can be overwhelming.

When Should You Take Your Personal Injury Case to Trial?

Taking your case to trial might be the right move if:

The offer you received is way lower than what you believe you deserve.

  • You believe that a jury might be sympathetic to your situation and award a higher amount.
  • You want to set a legal precedent to help others in similar situations.
  • Settling or Going to Court: The Right Legal Team Matters regardless of which path you choose, having the right legal team by your side is essential. A good lawyer can advise on the best course of action, negotiate effectively, and represent your interests, whether in a mediation session or a courtroom.


Is a Settlement Offer Still Valid if I Go to Trial?

Typically, once you decide to go to trial, previous settlement offers are off the table. However, negotiations can continue, and a new settlement can be reached even after a trial has started.

Can My Settlement Amount Get Affected If I Was Partly to Blame for the Accident?

Yes, in many places, if you’re found to be partly responsible for the accident, it can reduce the amount of compensation you receive. The exact amount depends on the laws of the region and the specifics of the case.


There’s no one-size-fits-all answer to whether settling out of court or going to trial is better. Each case is unique, and the best decision depends on the specifics of the situation. By understanding the advantages and drawbacks of settling out of court, you can make a more informed choice.

Free Injury Case Evaluation

Send the form below and we will call you back in minutes.

…or Call Us Now